We love them because they're the same, but different.

Jonathan Bennett is one of Hallmark’s biggest stars — and a prince of Christmas — but he’s ready to pass the torch. “We base challenges off the different tropes of the Hallmark movies that everyone's come to know and love,

"That line was such a huge deal," says co-creator, executive producer and host Jonathan Bennett, who bounced around holiday-themed phrases with lead judge Melissa Peterman. "I wanted it to be so cheeky that people laughed.